( With the Winchesters in town, he debates telling her more. But, he'd rather tell her about David's history himself. And everything it comes with. )

Well, the new member was a demon, and not who he claimed to be. That new member had it in for our coven because back then, it was billed more as a wellness cult. He wanted to steer things in the wrong direction. In a very short amount of time, the members were speaking differently, and taking very questionable advice. I didn't know right away. I just thought a rival coven was infiltrating. I was right about the infiltration. But not why. Or, who.